11/12/2026 | Press release | Archived content
Plaintiffs in the landmark desegregation case in Connecticut known as Sheff v. O'Neill filed a motion today in the Connecticut Superior Court in Hartford seeking to enforce an existing judicial order that protects the constitutional rights of Hartford-resident minority students to attend quality, integrated schools. The commitments made under Sheff v. O'Neill aim to advance equal educational opportunities by enabling Hartford area students to attend Sheff-related magnet schools, suburban schools through Open Choice, and other educational programs throughout the region.
On March 9, 2026, with the approval of the Hartford Board of Education, Hartford Public Schools entered into a contract with a third-party vendor, Caissa K12. Among other goals, the contract has the objective of recruiting Hartford students away from voluntary interdistrict programs that provide access to integrated educational settings. Caissa K12 receives compensation for every Hartford resident student that leaves a Sheff voluntary interdistrict program and enrolls in a Hartford neighborhood school.
The contract undermines the goals of the court order to create a sustainable system of integrated education throughout the Hartford Region. The contract also overrides the State of Connecticut's agreed-upon marketing plan and disrupts the application process established under the existing court order to ensure that students can access available educational opportunities. In doing so, Hartford is undermining the parties' court-ordered efforts to expand access to integrated education across the region.
Connecticut's State Department of Education unequivocally recognized that the Contract violates the judicial order. By allowing the contract to continue, the Plaintiffs argue, the State is failing to uphold its own commitments under the court order and bears responsibility for Hartford Public Schools' actions. Plaintiffs further argue that the City of Hartford, a party to the judicial order, also bears responsibility for Hartford Public Schools' actions.
Through this action, Plaintiffs ask the Court to enforce the judicial order and void the contract in order to preserve the commitments made under Sheff v. O'Neill.
"Some families have financial resources that allow them the privilege to choose an educational setting that they feel best suits the needs of their child. 'Sheff' presents families who do not have such an advantage with a free opportunity to do the same. I am baffled by those who wish to thwart the option to choose, and even more disturbed by the state's inaction to ensure that Hartford families can exercise that same freedom of choice, regardless of their ZIP code or household income." Elizabeth Horton Sheff, the lead plaintiff in the case.
"While the plaintiffs share the Hartford Public Schools' concerns relating to funding, these issues cannot be remedied on the backs of the thousands of Hartford children and youth who are currently enrolled in the 43 magnet schools and the Open Choice program established pursuant to the court orders in the Sheff case." Martha Stone, Founder and Special Counsel for the Center for Children's Advocacy, who has represented the plaintiffs since the case began in 1989.
"The students and families of Hartford deserve a sustained commitment to an integrated education system that maximizes access and does not place equal educational opportunity further out of reach," said Alexandra Thompson, LDF Senior Counsel. "The State has acknowledged that Hartford's third-party vendor contract violates the court order, yet has allowed it to move forward without intervention. The permanent injunction in Sheff v. O'Neill represents a commitment to ensuring that Hartford and Hartford-area students have meaningful and sustained educational opportunities to learn in integrated school settings. Those commitments must not be in name only; they require the State and all parties to take affirmative steps to protect and expand access for every Hartford child."
"Every Hartford student deserves the opportunity to access robust, diverse educational opportunities that support their ability to learn, grow, and thrive," said Pilar Whitaker, LDF Senior Counsel. "These programs open doors to educational experiences that students might otherwise not have, and Hartford Public Schools should be working to expand those opportunities, not diminish them. We cannot allow efforts to advance equal opportunity for Hartford students to be undermined."
###
Founded in 1940, the Legal Defense Fund (LDF) is the nation's first civil rights legal organization. LDF has been completely separate from the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) since 1957, though it was founded under the leadership of Thurgood Marshall while he was at the NAACP. LDF's Thurgood Marshall Institute (TMI) is a division of LDF that undertakes innovative research and houses LDF's archive. In all media attributions, please refer to us as the Legal Defense Fund or LDF (do not include NAACP) and refer to the Institute as LDF's Thurgood Marshall Institute or TMI.