The Senate Rules Committee should ensure that President Trump's two nominees to the Federal Election Committee (FEC) are committed to restoring the FEC's impartiality and reversing the partisan entrenchment which has left the FEC largely ineffective, according to a letter sent by CREW. Congress must ensure that FEC commissioners are dedicated to enacting a robust recusal policy, increasing transparency around decision making and restoring independence from partisan influence.
To ensure citizens' complaints are provided a fair hearing, the FEC must adopt a recusal policy that requires them to recuse not only when a commissioner has personal conflicts, but also if their partisan affinity impairs their ability to be impartial. The FEC currently lacks any mechanism to request, consider or enforce such recusals, which is concerning given the FEC's power to determine cases of national significance. In a particularly troubling case, then-Commissioner Trey Trainor refused to recuse from a FEC case related to the New York criminal prosecution of Trump for falsifying business records-despite Trainor's public support of Trump's candidacy and statements on the case that indicated his clear political bias. In 2024, CREW called for Trainor to recuse from the case, but received no response. Trainor even recently admitted that he voted to block FEC investigations into Trump out of "loyalty," demonstrating the critical need for a robust recusal policy.
When the FEC rejects recommendations from the agency's general counsel to investigate complaints, it should also be required to provide contemporaneous rationale. This would provide a much needed ethical guardrail for the FEC, which as it stands is often voting to close cases before commissioners have all of the relevant information and analysis. These new appointees should commit to placing in the administrative record their justification for voting against a general counsel's recommended investigation before the Commission votes to close a case.
Threats to the FEC's impartiality are not only internal. Trump recently asserted the power to fire commissioners at will-commissioners must reject Trump's executive order seeking to undo the FEC's longstanding independence and assure Congress they will faithfully and independently apply the law to the facts in their best judgment, without regard to the politics of the parties in front of them or their own partisanship.
Congress has an obligation to ensure the FEC operates fairly and that it earns the public's trust. FEC nominees who are unable to make commitments of recusal, transparency and independence to Congress and to the American public should not be trusted with the FEC's vital work on the front lines against corruption.