Study: Minority groups receive fewer economic and social opportunities at work, despite ‘colorblind’ argument

• For Journalists
• News Releases
• Latest Releases
• News Release

Study: Minority groups receive fewer economic and social opportunities at work, despite 'colorblind' argument

Research highlights the important role of social networks in the labor markets

CHICAGO --- The 2023 landmark Supreme Court decision effectively banning race-conscious affirmative action - along with the subsequent challenges to diversity, equity and inclusion in major corporations and military admissions - has brought back the decades-old argument for "merit-based" or "colorblind" policies.

New research conducted by Chika Okafor, an assistant professor of law at Northwestern Pritzker School of Law and fellow at the Institute for Policy Research at Northwestern, shows that social network discrimination - the phenomenon in which minorities suffer disadvantages in economic and social opportunities simply because their social group is smaller - occurs because people tend to form social connections with others who resemble, behave and hail from a similar background.

The study, "Seeing through Color Blindness: Social Networks as a Mechanism for Discrimination," was published today (September 10) in the Journal of Law & Economics.

"If we care about fairness and about true equality of opportunity, we should care about this work," Okafor said. "This paper mathematically disproves a proposition that colorblindness inherently promotes merit. We need to have more open and honest conversations about how to truly advance our society in light of the implications of social network discrimination.

"I grounded my paper in economic theory," said Okafor, who's an economist. "This allowed me to distill from a mathematical perspective a new and important driver of disparities between majority and minority groups. With these insights, one can then incorporate historical, sociological and even legal perspectives to better explore the implications of my findings not only for American society - but also for other communities around the world."

'Social networks play a huge role in labor markets'

Okafor found that minorities are less likely to be referred for a job because they form fewer social connections with existing employees, particularly in a setting with colorblind hiring when characteristics of the groups are fully equal except for group size.

"Social networks play a huge role in labor markets," Okafor said. "Despite initial equality in ability, employment, wages and network structure, minorities receive disproportionately fewer jobs through referrals and lower expected wages, simply because their social group is smaller."

Okafor's research also found that minorities can expect lower wages. He used real-world data to estimate that the minimum difference in expected wages caused by social network discrimination is at least 3.2%, disadvantaging minority workers. He described this as the minimum difference between groups because it is based purely on differences in group size. His estimate does not incorporate other important factors that would increase the wage gap between majority and minority workers in the U.S., such as historical discrimination, prejudice and inequality.

Okafor added that his research adds critical elements to the ongoing debate about colorblindness, diversity and merit.

"Much of the arguments we have heard for decades promote the view that colorblind policies inherently promote individual merit and move us closer to a meritocracy," he said. "My mathematical findings show that even if we hypothetically lived in a seemingly utopian world where everyone was starting off on equal footing and there were colorblind policies, minorities would still face disadvantages in social and economic opportunities over time because of social network dynamics arising from their group size being smaller. My findings do not only relate to hiring, but to any setting in which social networks matter - from company boardrooms to college classrooms. This complicates the commonplace narrative for colorblind polices."

As his research evolves, Okafor wants to dig deeper into how society can respond to social network discrimination, particularly to identify interventions that can help promote true equality of opportunity across America.

Interview soundbites

Professor Chika Okafor discusses his recent study, "Seeing through Color Blindness: Social Networks as a Mechanism for Discrimination."

Download All (.zip file)