Richard J. Durbin

11/18/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/19/2026 16:31

As Republicans Shirk Committee Norms, Durbin Grills Judicial Nominees About Their Lack Of Judicial Temperament, Involvement In Baseless Prosecution Of James Comey

November 18, 2026

As Republicans Shirk Committee Norms, Durbin Grills Judicial Nominees About Their Lack Of Judicial Temperament, Involvement In Baseless Prosecution Of James Comey

WASHINGTON - U.S. Senate Democratic Whip Dick Durbin (D-IL), Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, today questioned judicial nominees during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing with two panels beginning with Justice James Cody Hiland, nominated to be a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. During the second panel, Durbin pressed Philip Lawrence Aubart, nominated to the Middle District of North Carolina; Judge Brian Meyers, nominated to the Eastern District of North Carolina; and Justice James Sullivan, nominated to the Western District of Texas.

Before questioning Justice Hiland about his temperament, Durbin raised the alarm about Republicans abandoning the longstanding 28-day-rule, which requires that the Committee receive a nominee's Senate Judiciary Questionnaire at least 28 days before their hearing. Justice Hiland's Questionnaire was transmitted just seven days ago.

"You're asking to be given that opportunity for life, for the rest of your natural life, to serve in that capacity. To say that we take this seriously is exactly what we're supposed to do up here," Durbin said to Justice Hiland. "We're asked to ask serious questions so we can understand whether you are right for that job. It is also quite possible that we are troubled by the fact that we've had the response to your extensive questionnaires about your background, we've had access to that for seven days. That's it. You would be the shortest period of time of any nominee that we received a questionnaire in the 28 years I've served on this Committee. To think we're asking tough questions, that's the reason. We have limited opportunity to review your background, and you are seeking the second highest court in the land for a lifetime appointment."

Durbin then pressed Justice Hiland about his lack of judicial temperament when White House staff offered him a nomination to a district court in August 2026 rather than a nomination to the Eighth Circuit, which he was expecting. Months after he rejected the nomination to the district court vacancy, Justice Hiland was nominated to the Eighth Circuit after the Trump Administration withdrew Judge Lee Rudofsky's nomination to the seat. Durbin questioned Justice Hiland on whether he has the temperament to serve in this lifetime appointment.

"In August, you spoke to a group of law students about the selection process to the federal bench. You told them that you had expected to receive a call from President Trump informing you of his intent to nominate you to this Eighth Circuit. Instead, you received a call from staff at the White House asking if you would be interested in filling a district court vacancy. Calling yourself 'belligerent,' you declined the offer. When asked by White House staff if they should 'go back into the Oval Office and tell the President of the United States that you're rejecting an opportunity to be appointed to the federal bench?' You responded, 'Yes, that's exactly what I want you to tell the President of the United States,'" Durbin said.

"Do you still consider yourself 'belligerent?'" Durbin asked Justice Hiland. "Can you control your emotions if you're given this opportunity?" Durbin asked.

Justice Hiland claimed that his career as a prosecuting attorney and Arkansas Supreme Court justice has shown that he is capable of separating his emotions from the facts.

Durbin then asked Justice Hiland about a recent scandal at the Office of Professional Programs, which is overseen by the Arkansas Supreme Court, where he has served since 2023. In 2026, Nancie Givens, the former executive director of the Arkansas Office of Professional Programs, was arrested and charged with 65 felony counts of tampering with a public record. Investigators allege that, between July 2020 and July 2025, Givens had been deliberately altering bar exam scores. According to a press release signed by six of the seven justices on the Arkansas Supreme Court, including Justice Hiland, the court was informed about the irregularities in test scores and recordkeeping as early as February 2026; however, the criminal investigation was not initiated until April 2026. Further, a seal order has been put in place, eliminating any transparency about where the case stands.

"Earlier this month, the former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court's Office of Professional Programs was arrested and charged with 65 felony counts for allegedly tampering with bar exam scores in the state of Arkansas, including adding points to scores that allowed them to pass rather than fail. The alleged misconduct took place between 2020 and 2025. You have sat on the Supreme Court since 2023… When were you first made aware of these irregularities with the bar exams?" Durbin asked Justice Hiland.

Justice Hiland claimed he was made aware in May of this year, though months earlier he had signed the press release issued by the Arkansas Supreme Court noting that it was aware of the test score irregularities.

"When were the individuals who should have failed the bar exam but are now practicing notified of the discrepancies in their scoring?" Durbin asked.

Justice Hiland replied that because this is an ongoing criminal investigation, there has been no communication with those who were incorrectly informed that they had passed the bar exam.

"For clarity, I would like to have you state for the record, under oath, whether you played any role… in the wrongdoing that's been alleged," Durbin said.

Justice Hiland said he was not involved in any wrongdoing.

Video of Durbin's questions in Committee for Panel I is available here.

Audio of Durbin's questions in Committee for Panel I is available here.

Footage of Durbin's questions in Committee for Panel I is available here for TV Stations.

During the second panel, Durbin grilled Justice Sullivan about his nomination to the Western District of Texas, which the Committee was notified of just one day after he lost his election to the Texas Supreme Court and only two weeks before his scheduled hearing.

"What an amazing story. I have been a candidate in a lot of elections, but I've never had a consolation prize like this. So here you are running for the Texas Supreme Court, and you don't know you have lost until the night before, but yet you have a Questionnaire filled out to file the next day for this federal court position. What am I missing here?" Durbin asked Justice Sullivan.

Justice Sullivan said that he first expressed interest in federal judicial service in March 2025.

"You certainly have friends in high places if you can lose an election one night and file a Questionnaire the next morning for a different judgeship. That's quite a rebound," Durbin replied.

Durbin then turned to Mr. Aubart and Judge Meyers, asking them about their involvement in the Trump Administration's efforts to prosecute former FBI Director James Comey. Durbin first asked Mr. Aubart about his time serving as the First Assistant U.S. Attorney in the Eastern District of North Carolina.

"At President Trump's urging, the Justice Department is implausibly claiming that former FBI Director Mr. Comey threatened to kill the President because he posted a picture of seashells in the formation of '86 47' on social media….You [have] served as First Assistant U.S. Attorney in the Eastern District of North Carolina since 2025…[The First Assistant] typically oversees the office's operations and supervises a large staff of prosecutors and professional staff…yet you have taken an unusually hands-on approach to the Comey prosecution," Durbin said.

"In April 2026, you and a case agent directed the FBI to conduct keyword searches of trial transcripts from U.S. vs. Gambino, a case Comey prosecuted more than 30 years ago. What were you looking for?" Durbin asked Mr. Aubart.

Mr. Aubart said he was searching for any reference to "86" during the Gambino trial.

"Did you find it?" Durbin followed up.

Mr. Aubart said he found no reference to "86."

"You traveled around the country to interview multiple witnesses, including to Phoenix. What did you do in Phoenix?" Durbin continued.

"Sammy the Bull was interviewed in Phoenix," Mr. Aubart replied, referring to Salvator Gravano, who was a witness in the Gambino trial.

"What did he have to do with seashells?" Durbin pressed.

Mr. Aubart said he spoke with Mr. Gravano about his knowledge of the term "86," but Mr. Aubart declined to provide additional details about their conversation.

"Did this case ever come up in your interviews with the Justice Department or the White House Counsel Office for this judgeship?" Durbin asked Mr. Aubart.

Mr. Aubart said he raised it as a potential topic of questioning during his nomination hearing.

Durbin then asked Judge Meyers about his involvement in the Comey prosecution as he was the U.S. Magistrate Judge who signed off on the search warrant for the personal email accounts and search history of Director Comey and his wife. Two months after signing the search warrants, Judge Meyers was contacted by U.S. Senator Ted Budd (R-NC) about his interest in serving as a district judge.

"Did this case ever come up in your interviews with the Justice Department or the White House Counsel?" Durbin asked Judge Meyers.

Judge Meyers replied that it did not.

Video of Durbin's questions in Committee for Panel II is available here.

Audio of Durbin's questions in Committee for Panel II is available here.

Footage of Durbin's questions in Committee for Panel II is available here for TV Stations.

-30-

Richard J. Durbin published this content on November 18, 2026, and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed via Public Technologies (PUBT), unedited and unaltered, on November 19, 2026 at 22:31 UTC. If you believe the information included in the content is inaccurate or outdated and requires editing or removal, please contact us at [email protected]