11/20/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/20/2026 15:32
NEW YORK - New York Attorney General Letitia James today announced a court victory permanently shutting down Otsego County vape shop owners who repeatedly sold flavored vapes to minors. In October 2025, Attorney General James sued Eysa Sharhan and Ahmed Mozeb for violating the New York Public Health Law and New York Tax Law and taking extreme measures to evade state enforcement. Now, the Otsego County Supreme Court has ordered Sharhan and Mozeb to close their Oneonta stores, banned them from ever selling vapes in New York again, and ordered them to pay $534,550 in fines, penalties, and costs. Sharhan and Mozeb ran three smoke shops, which they reopened under three different names each time the state took action against them.
"These owners sold addictive, illegal flavored vapes to young people, and every time the state shut them down, they reopened under a new name," said Attorney General James. "When we first filed this case, I said our children's health and safety are nonnegotiable, and I am pleased that the court agreed. These owners will never sell vapes in New York again, and they will pay for breaking the law. My office will continue to take on any business that puts profits over our children's health."
"Nicotine can harm the developing adolescent brain, and vaping puts young people's lungs and overall health at risk," said State Health Commissioner Dr. James McDonald. "Protecting young New Yorkers from the harms of vaping takes both education and enforcement. The Department of Health's Bureau of Investigations conducted a multi-year investigation that it brought to the Office of the Attorney General. We are grateful to Attorney General James and her team for enforcing the laws meant to prevent our children from vaping, and this result shows what our partnership can accomplish."
Attorney General James sued Sharhan and Mozeb after a multi-year investigation led by the New York State Department of Health (DOH) uncovered a pattern of illegal sales at Sharhan's and Mozeb's businesses, including the illegal sale of flavored vapes and repeated sales to underage customers. Under New York law, the retail sale of flavored vapor products with nicotine is strictly prohibited, and no person may sell any nicotine product to individuals under 21.
The Otsego County Supreme Court granted Attorney General James' petition, finding that the owners' continued sale of illegal products, "particularly to minors, exposes them to heightened risks for addiction and long-term illness and death." The court permanently barred Sharhan, Mozeb, and their companies, Pop-In Smoke & Vape, Pufftopia, and Royalty Tobacco, from selling, marketing, or distributing vapes. They are also barred from owning, operating, or managing any business that sells vapes, and are prohibited from getting a license to sell vapes. The court also ordered the owners to remove all vapes from their stores on State Highway 7 in Oneonta and close the stores.
In addition, the court has ordered Sharhan, Mozeb, and their companies to pay $534,550, including $514,500 in penalties, $10,050 in outstanding DOH fines, and $10,000 in court costs. The owners must also pay to safely dispose of the flavored vapes they left behind at Royalty Tobacco.
Attorney General James thanks Commissioner McDonald and DOH for their partnership in this case.
This matter was handled for OAG by Assistant Attorney General Charissa Kim, with assistance from Assistant Attorneys General Carol Hunt and Joy Mele, Legal Assistants Ketty Dautruche, Dana-Ann Henry, and Karen Swett, and Administrative Assistant Megan McDaniel, under the supervision of Health Care Bureau Chief Darsana Srinivasan and Deputy Bureau Chief Leslieann Cachola. The Health Care Bureau is part of the Division for Social Justice, which is overseen by First Deputy Attorney General Meghan Faux.