11/20/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/20/2026 14:36
|
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Date: November 20, 2026 |
|
Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer Asks California Supreme Court
to Immediately Block Governor Newsom from Commuting Death Sentences of 18 Orange County
Condemned Inmates; This is the Second Legal Challenge Spitzer has Filed This Week
Opposing Governor Newsom's Mass Commutation of Death Row Inmates
On Monday, Spitzer also filed an amicus curiae arguing Newsom abused his power in moving to commute the
death sentences of 382 condemned inmates with prior felony convictions without conducting an individualized review of each case.
SANTA ANA, Calif. - Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer has asked the California Supreme Court to immediately block California Governor Gavin Newsom from commuting the death sentences of the 18 Orange County condemned inmates which are not subject to Supreme Court review, accusing the governor of violating the California Constitution and the separation of powers when he issued a blanket commutation of all 548 of California's death sentences. This is the second legal challenge Spitzer has filed with the California Supreme Court this week challenging the governor's mass commutations.
The California Supreme Court has ordered the state's Solicitor General to respond within 10 days to District Attorney Spitzer's arguments related to the 18 Orange County condemned inmates who would not have to have their commutations reviewed by the Supreme Court because they do not have a prior felony conviction.
Earlier this week, District Attorney Spitzer filed an amicus curiae brief with the California Supreme Court, arguing Governor Newsom abused his power when he imposed a mass commutation of the death sentences of 382 condemned inmates with prior felony convictions simply because he disagrees with the death penalty. The brief also accuses the governor of failing to follow the proper process when he failed to conduct an individualized review of each case before moving to commute the death sentences to life without the possibility of parole.
On Thursday, November 5, 2026, Governor Newsom announced in a letter to Californians that he was commuting the death sentences for all 548 of California's condemned inmates to sentences of life without the possibility of parole. The move marks the largest mass commutation in United States history.
"The Governor's stated basis for sparing every condemned inmate is that he believes the State should never carry out a death sentence. Because of his categorical opposition to the executions provided for by law, the Governor has expressly admitted that nothing about any of the particular individuals' offenses, individual circumstances, rehabilitative prospects, or public risk would change the result," the Orange County District Attorney's Office's amicus reads.
Out of the 548 condemned inmates, 382 have been previously convicted of a felony in a separate case in addition to the conviction for which they were sentenced to death. Thirty of those are Orange County condemned inmates. California law requires the commutations of those twice-convicted felons to be reviewed by the California Supreme Court and upheld by a majority of the California Supreme Court justices. The remaining 166 commutations, of which 18 are Orange County condemned inmates, do not require Supreme Court review.
California voters have twice rejected initiatives that not only would have abolished the death penalty - but would have automatically converted every existing death sentence to life without the possibility of parole. California voters have also demanded the death penalty process be sped up.
"The governor is putting his finger in the wind to gauge the direction he needs to take to fulfill his political ambition to be president of the United States and it is clear with this action that he and his advisors believe he needs to run even further to the left to become his party's 2028 nominee," said Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer. "This is not a debate about who should live and who should die, as those decisions have already been made by a jury of their peers and repeatedly upheld through the appellate process. This is an attack on democracy, and the determination of one man to use his power to suppress the will of millions of Californians who rejected abolishing the death penalty. This decision commanders the rule of law and allows the governor to act as judge and jury while refusing to act as executioner. The pursuit of justice will never end, and we will continue to fight to uphold the law."
The Orange County District Attorney's Writ of Mandate filed with the California Supreme Court asks for the immediate stay of the commutations of:
Alfaro, Maria del Rosio
Maria del Rosio "Rosie" Alfaro was sentenced to death in 1992 for fatally stabbing 9-year-old Autumn Wallace during a burglary and robbery of her family's home in Anaheim Hills in 1990. Wallace, home alone after school, let Alfaro in the house because she recognized her as an acquaintance of her older sister. Alfaro stabbed the little girl more than 50 times. She was the first woman in Orange County to get the death penalty at 20.
Amulu, Ika
Convicted of special circumstance murders of Matthew Francis Scott, a sales associate and son of the business co-owner, and longtime secretary Elizabeth Ann Palmer because he wanted to steal a Lexus from their business. He was previously convicted in other special circumstance murders. Sentenced to death in 2014.
Avila, Alejandro
Alejandro Avila was convicted in 2005 for the 2002 kidnapping, sexual assault, and first-degree murder of 5-year-old Samantha Runnion in Stanton, California. Linked to the crime via DNA, tire tracks, and phone records, he received a death sentence that was unanimously upheld by the California Supreme Court in 2014.
Bennett, Eric Wayne
Bludgeoned 50-year-old Marie Evans Powell to death during a burglary and rape at her townhouse in Laguna Hills two weeks after laying carpet in the woman's house. He was also linked and convicted of a separate rape and robbery of a woman at knifepoint in Costa Mesa. He was sentenced to death in 1997, and the California Supreme Court affirmed the conviction in 2009.
Boyer, Richard Delmer
On December 7, 1982, Boyer stabbed an elderly couple, 67-year-old Francis Harbitz and 68-year-old Aileen Harbitz, to death in Fullerton. He stabbed the husband 24 times and the wife 19 times. Boyer claimed the opening murders in Halloween II were the reason for committing the double murders.
Burney, Shaun Kareem
An Orange County grand jury indicted Burney, 18, along with co-defendants Allen Dean Burnett II (20) and Scott Boxer Rembert, on second-degree robbery, kidnapping, kidnapping for purposes of robbery, and first-degree murder of 21-year-old college student Joseph Kondrath. Kondrath was shot in the head after the three men stole his car and threw him in his own trunk before executing him to avoid being identified. Burney was convicted of first-degree murder, kidnapping, kidnapping for robbery, and second-degree robbery with special circumstances in 1994. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit rejected his habeas corpus petition in 2026.
Charles, Edward, III
In November 1994, Edward Charles III, 22, killed his 55-year-old father, Edward Charles II, his 47-year-old mother, Dolores Charles, and his 19-year-old brother, Danny Charles, in Fullerton. Charles abducted Danny after dinner, stabbed him, broke his hyoid bone, and killed him by striking his head repeatedly with a 16-inch crescent wrench. He then returned to the parents' home, strangled his mother, and beat his father to death with a blunt object. The bodies were placed in Danny's car, which Charles later burned at El Camino High School's parking lot. He was sentenced to death in 1999.
DeHoyos, Richard Lucio
DeHoyos was convicted of kidnaping, raping and murdering a 9-year-old Santa Ana girl whom he lured into his car by posing as a schoolteacher. He sexually assaulted 9-year-old Nadia Puente in a Santa Ana motel room and suffocated her. Nadia's body was found stuffed in a garbage can in Los Angeles' Griffith Park.
Famalaro, John Joseph
Known as the "Cold Storage Killer, John Famalaro posed as a police officer and abducted 23-year-old Denise Huber at gunpoint in June 1991 when she stopped on the Corona del Mar Freeway to change a flat tire. Famalaro drove her to a warehouse in Laguna Hills where he sexually assaulted her, bound her, and bludgeoned her to death, hitting her with a hammer and crowbar more than 31 times. He placed her naked body in a plastic bag and stored it in an industrial-grade freezer in his mobile storage truck.
Kraft, Randy Steven
Randy Steven Kraft is a serial killer and rapist known as the Scorecard Killer, the Southern California Strangler, and the Freeway Killer, who committed the rape, torture, and murder of a minimum of sixteen young men between 1972 and 1983, the majority of whom he killed in California. Kraft is also believed to have committed the rape and murder of 51 other young men and boys.
Livingston, Waymon
Waymon Livingston was convicted of the sexual assault and murder of 21-year-old Melissa G., along with three rapes and an aggravated assault committed in Orange County between 2005 and 2007, after DNA and forensic evidence linked him to the crimes.
Miranda-Guerrero, Victor Mirando
Victor M. Miranda-Guerrero was convicted of kidnapping to commit rape, murder, attempted carjacking, assault with intent to commit rape, and receiving stolen property for a series of attacks in Huntington Beach, including the 1999 rape and murder of Bridgette Ballas, whose battered body was found partially undressed in the street after a sexual assault. The jury found true the special circumstance that the murder occurred during the commission or attempted commission of rape, returned a death verdict, and the California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment.
Monterroso, Christian Antonio
Christian Monterroso was sentenced to death for a 1991 killing spree in Anaheim in which he robbed two convenience stores and murdered clerks Tarsem Singh and Ashokkumar Patel within hours of each other. During the first robbery, Monterroso held multiple hostages before executing Singh, then later fatally shot Patel during a second robbery.
Murtaza, Iftekhar
Murtaza was convicted of orchestrating a revenge-murder plot against the family of his ex-girlfriend after their relationship ended in 2007, leading to the murders of his ex-girlfriend's father, Jaypraykash Dhanak, and her older sister Karishma Dhanak and the attempted murder of her mother Leela Dhanak by beating her with a baseball bat. After recruiting accomplices, helping kidnap and attack the family, setting their Anaheim Hills home on fire, and arranging for Jaypraykash and Karishma to be set on fire, Murtaza was convicted of murder, attempted murder, and conspiracy, and he was sentenced to death.
Nelson, Tanya Jaime
Tanya Jaime Nelson was convicted of the special-circumstances murders of Ha Smith, a Westminster fortune teller, and her daughter, Anita Vo, after traveling from North Carolina to Orange County in 2005 and killing them during a planned robbery for jewelry and other valuables. After the murders, Nelson and co-defendant Phillipe Zamora ransacked the home, stole property, and attempted to conceal the crime; prosecutors sought the death penalty based on multiple-murder, robbery-murder, and lying-in-wait special circumstances.
Tafoya, Ignacio Arriola
Ignacio A. Tafoya was convicted of the 1993 robbery, burglary, and murders of Gerald Skillman and Steven Rita after he and an accomplice forced their way into a Westminster home and shot the victims during a robbery. The jury found multiple special-circumstance allegations true, sentenced Tafoya to death, and the California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in its entirety.
Vargas, Eduardo David
Eduardo David Vargas was convicted of first-degree murder, multiple robberies and attempted robberies, gang-related offenses, and unlawfully possessing a firearm while on probation; the jury also found he personally discharged a firearm causing death during a robbery and acted to benefit a criminal street gang. Following the jury's finding of a robbery-murder special circumstance and a penalty trial, he was sentenced to death, and the judgment was affirmed on automatic appeal.
Wozniak, Daniel Patrick
Wozniak was convicted of two counts of murder in September 2016. In May 2010, Wozniak killed his neighbor and friend, Private First Class Sam Herr, and Herr's friend, Juri "Julie" Kibuishi, as part of a plan to frame Herr for Kibuishi's murder and steal his combat pay. Wozniak was deeply in debt and wanted money to finance his upcoming wedding and honeymoon. Wozniak dismembered Herr's body and littered Herr's head and body parts in a park. Sentenced to death.
Click here for full press release.
Click here for full brief.