Chess.com LLC

11/21/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/21/2026 13:19

FIDE Calls Carlsen's Forfeits 'Unacceptable,' Refers Him To Ethics Commission

FIDE will refer GM Magnus Carlsen's conduct at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot to its Ethics and Disciplinary Commission (EDC), describing his forfeits as "unacceptable." The tournament's arbiters will also face a separate review of their handling of the incidents.

The statement, published on Saturday and signed by FIDE president Timur Turlov and its deputy president GM Viswanathan Anand, follows five forfeited games by Carlsen over the final four days in Budapest. The world number-one finished 17th after skipping Friday's fast classical game against GM Vladislav Artemiev, then winning the deciding armageddon game.

❗️FIDE Statement on the Conclusion of the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026❗️ Following the conclusion of the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026 in Budapest, the International Chess Federation (FIDE) congratulates the medalists, GM Alireza Firouzja, GM Anish Giri, and GM Fabiano Caruana. FIDE also extends its thanks to Kjell Madland, the entire Total Chess team, and the Hungarian hosts for organizing this important pilot event ahead of the inaugural full season of the Tour in 2027. At the same time, FIDE expresses serious concern over several instances of players forfeiting scheduled games during the tournament. Some of these forfeits, including those by GM Magnus Carlsen, occurred in matches whose outcomes had already been mathematically decided. Although such actions breached the tournament regulations requiring all scheduled games to be played, they did not affect the results of the respective matches. However, GM Magnus Carlsen also forfeited three scheduled games over two days of his match against GM Vladislav Artemiev while the outcomes of the respective contests were still undecided. Such conduct undermines the principles of fair play and the fairness of the competition and is unprecedented at the highest level of professional chess. These forfeited games had a significant meaning, seriously impacting the very top of the rating standings. FIDE considers such conduct unacceptable and inconsistent with the standards of professional behavior expected of participants in official competitions. Given GM Carlsen's stature and his significant role in promoting chess, such actions are particularly concerning, as they may damage the reputation of competitions and demonstrate a lack of respect for opponents, spectators, and tournament partners. Accordingly, FIDE will refer the relevant materials to the FIDE Ethics and Disciplinary Commission (EDC) for an independent assessment of potential violations of the FIDE Ethics and Disciplinary Code. Furthermore, the officiating during the event fell short of fundamental standards, as the arbiters effectively abdicated their responsibility to uphold the FIDE Laws of Chess and tournament regulations. Accordingly, the actions of the arbiters involved will be referred to the FIDE Arbiters' Commission (ARB) and its Disciplinary Sub-Committee (DSC) for thorough examination and assessment. As the Budapest event was intended to test the competition format and regulations ahead of the 2027 season, FIDE will continue working closely with Total Chess to refine the rules governing player forfeits and their consequences in order to prevent similar incidents in the future. FIDE reaffirms its commitment to ensuring that all official competitions are conducted in accordance with the principles of fairness, sporting integrity, and respect for all participants. Timur Turlov FIDE President Viswanathan Anand FIDE Deputy President Total Chess / Michal Walusza

- International Chess Federation (@FIDE_chess) November 21, 2026

FIDE noted the difference between skipping games after a match was already decided, such as against GM Bibisara Assaubayeva, and Carlsen's three forfeits against Artemiev: two rapid games on Thursday and the fast classical game on Friday.

"Such repeated misconduct undermines the principles of fair play and the fairness of the competition and is unprecedented at the highest level of professional chess," they noted about his forfeits against Artemiev.

Such repeated misconduct undermines the principles of fair play and the fairness of the competition and is unprecedented at the highest level of professional chess.
-FIDE statement

"FIDE considers such conduct unacceptable and inconsistent with the standards of professional behavior expected of participants in official competitions," the statement continued.

"Given GM Carlsen's stature and his significant role in promoting chess, such actions are particularly concerning, as they may damage the reputation of competitions and demonstrate a lack of respect for opponents, spectators, and tournament partners."

FIDE also said the forfeited games had seriously affected the top of the rating standings. Unplayed games do not affect a player's rating, meaning Carlsen's forfeits avoided the rating risk of playing them.

Magnus Carlsen eventually won the match against Vladislav Artemiev. Photo: Total Chess.

With the case now being referred to the EDC for an independent review, Carlsen could face a disciplinary sanction, including a warning, a fine, or a suspension, if the EDC finds that he breached its code.

He has previously been sanctioned by the commission. In December 2023, the EDC fined him €10,000 for withdrawing without valid reason from the 2022 Sinquefield Cup following his loss to GM Hans Niemann. He was cleared of the other three charges in that case.

Carlsen is not the only one who could face repercussions. FIDE is also critical of the arbiters conduct at the event, saying they had "effectively abdicated their responsibility to uphold the FIDE Laws of Chess and tournament regulations." Their actions have been referred to the FIDE Arbiters' Commission and its Disciplinary Sub-Committee.

Carlsen faced criticism from several of his fellow grandmasters during the event. One of them was GM Fabiano Caruana, who said:

"I don't think it's good at all. I don't think it was good the first time... but this is even worse because you are leaving in the middle of the match. I think you should just forfeit the match if you don't play," he told ChessBase India.

He later made a tennis comparison.

"To me, its like in Tennis someone decided to drop the 2nd set and come back for the 3rd set. I don't think I've seen anything like this in chess or any other sport!" - Fabiano Caruana on Magnus Carlsen not playing the Fast Classic game against Artemiev. https://t.co/JfNZQd2XFq

- ChessBase India (@ChessbaseIndia) November 21, 2026

GM Ian Nepomniachtchi went further, calling for Carlsen's removal from the event. "I think the player has to be expelled from the tournament," he said, also describing the conduct as "disrespect."

GM Maxime Vachier-Lagrave described the tournament as a worthwhile experiment, but added: "I'm a bit sad that some of the players decided to make their own headlines."

Vachier-Lagrave then sharpened that criticism in a reply on X, apparently referring to Carlsen:

Correction: that a crybaby decided to make his own headlines.

- MVL (@Vachier_Lagrave) November 20, 2026

GM Levon Aronian shared a different perspective. "This event did make me melancholic and sad, but people change and sometimes not for better," he wrote on X. "For people who are disappointed with Magnus Carlsen i want you to see his actions as a blessing for chess."

Happy to finish Total Chess Pilot. My play was not great, but it was first time we played 45+30 time control and I got to like it, even though i think 15 minutes after move 40 would greatly improve the quality of the games and still keep it exciting. Congrats to @AlirezaFirouzja and @anishgiri (especially!!) for showing amazing skills and my old buddies @FabianoCaruana and @Vachier_Lagrave for being their usual great! This event did make me melancholic and sad,but people change and sometimes not for better. For people who are disappointed with @MagnusCarlsen i want you to see his actions as a blessing for chess. New generation plays hard and shows their hunger. Look them in the eyes, they are exceptional players, intelligent and kind people. We have a world of potential and i feel that the players have the full support to make positive changes in every aspect of the game. What else do we need?

- Levon Aronian (@LevAronian) November 21, 2026

Former FIDE presidential candidate and tournament organizer Wadim Rosenstein defended Carlsen, arguing that the controversy exposed problems with the tournament's incentives as well as questions of individual responsibility.

"I stand firmly in defence of Magnus Carlsen following the controversy at the Total Chess pilot tournament in Budapest," he wrote on X.

Rosenstein said Assaubayeva deserved an opponent and proper communication, and acknowledged the reported instruction that all scheduled games had to be played. But he questioned a system in which a player who had already secured the result could lose rating points by drawing the remaining game, while forfeiting it carried no rating cost.

"Why did the tournament regulations create a situation in which not playing was more beneficial than playing?" he asked.

I stand firmly in defence of Magnus Carlsen following the controversy at the Total Chess pilot tournament in Budapest. When senior FIDE officials, including Deputy President Anand and Advisor Sutovsky, publicly criticised Magnus for missing scheduled games, they raised legitimate questions about sporting responsibility. Anand questioned Carlsen's decision while also acknowledging that the tournament regulations needed improvement. Sutovsky went further, publicly describing his conduct as "pathetic" and "unsportsmanlike." Every player who sits down at the board deserves an opponent. Bibisara certainly deserved that respect, and I believe Magnus should have ensured she was informed of his decision. However, I believe we are overlooking a much bigger problem. Why did the tournament regulations create a situation in which not playing was more beneficial than playing? By the time Magnus was scheduled to face Bibisara, he had already won their match. According to the chief arbiter's explanation, he consulted the arbiters before the game. Forfeiting the remaining game would count as a loss in the match but would not affect his classical rating. Had he played and drawn, he would still have won the match but would have lost rating points because of the rating difference. Think about that. The regulations effectively created an incentive for a player to stay away from the board rather than compete. Magnus later missed two rapid games against Vladislav and acknowledged that rating considerations influenced his decision. I am not suggesting that every decision Magnus made was correct. Nor am I ignoring the reported instruction that all scheduled games were expected to be played. But if tournament regulations create incentives that contradict the fundamental principles of sporting competition, we must examine those regulations rather than focus exclusively on criticising individual players. And this brings me to another important issue. I call upon senior FIDE officials, including Mr Anand and Mr Sutovsky, to demonstrate neutrality, professionalism and institutional responsibility. Of course, officials are entitled to personal opinions. But when someone holds a senior position in an international sports federation, their public statements carry additional weight. I find it concerning when senior officials publicly criticise athletes over controversies arising from competitions within the international chess system without placing sufficient emphasis on examining the underlying regulations. Public criticism of individual athletes should never become a substitute for institutional accountability. Their responsibility should be to identify problems, establish the facts and help improve the system. Players are expected to respect the rules. Officials must be expected to take responsibility for them. This principle applies to everyone, regardless of their name, reputation or position. I have always said: Chess is not merely a game. Chess is a sport. And professional sport requires professional governance. If a game remains mandatory after the match has been decided, the regulations must clearly establish that obligation and meaningful consequences for failing to play. If the game serves no further competitive purpose, organisers should consider ending the match. What cannot become normal is a system where avoiding competition offers a better outcome than competing. Budapest was a pilot tournament. That is precisely why these problems should be identified and corrected before the format develops further. My position is clear: Bibisara deserved respect and proper communication. Magnus deserved clear, consistent regulations. FIDE and Norway Chess must examine the incentives created by the tournament format. And senior officials must demonstrate the same accountability they demand from athletes. I defend Magnus not because he is Magnus Carlsen, but because the principle matters for every chess player.

- Wadim Rosenstein (@WadimRosenstein) November 21, 2026

On Friday, Carlsen shared his own explanation for his actions with TV 2 reporter Sverre Krogh Sundbo.

Asked whether he had skipped the final classical game to protect his rating, he pointed to how he was feeling. "If I'd been feeling great, I would have played. But I feel... tired and fed up. I didn't feel like playing at all."

If I'd been feeling great, I would have played. But I feel... tired and fed up. I didn't feel like playing at all.
-Magnus Carlsen

On the question of whether he would speak to the players who had strongly criticized him, Carlsen said."The problem is simply that we have very different goals, and we're in different places. It's as simple as that," he said.

"I think everyone else cares about the classical world championship. I don't. I think many have a different view of what top-level chess should be like."

Magnus Carlsen signing autographs during the Total Chess Pilot in Budapest. Photo: Tor Nilssen/Total Chess.

He also spoke openly about the freedom his status gives him. "For many years, I've been very used to being able to do things somewhat on my own terms, because tournament organizers of all kinds need me more than I need them. Financially, this isn't important to me. So you often make somewhat cynical, selfish choices."

I've been very used to being able to do things somewhat on my own terms, because tournament organizers of all kinds need me more than I need them.
-Magnus Carlsen

In a separate TV 2 interview earlier that day, Carlsen described a "negative spiral" caused by arriving with little motivation and wanting to be with his family. "That has become very clear, that I'd rather be home than be here," he said.

He noted that beginning an event with little motivation was a poor starting point, and that his initial feelings had amplified everything that followed. He told TV 2 that he had felt some obligation to support the first event because he had previously advocated combining formats.

Carlsen was also unhappy with how his words had been interpreted. "What annoys me the absolute most in the chess world is that people do not believe me on what I say," he said. "I always speak exactly what I think and exactly how I intend it."

What annoys me the absolute most in the chess world is that people do not believe me on what I say. I always speak exactly what I think and exactly how I intend it.
-Magnus Carlsen

On Thuesday, Carlsen also admitted that rating played a role in his decision to skip the rapid games against Artemiev. He was in danger of dropping below 2800 in both classical and rapid.

"I understand the point, but rating does matter somewhat. I felt I had no energy to play rapid chess at all. Of course it's cynical, but we're playing for 17th place, so rating points and things like that matter," he told TV 2.

The controversy began after Carlsen went winless in his 10 group-stage fast classical games and was left competing for places 17-20. On Tuesday, he secured a clear 11.5-0.5 lead against Assaubayeva, then declined to play the final game. Assaubayeva waited through the 15-minute default period before receiving a forfeit win.

According to TV 2 reporter Sundbo, Carlsen had looked for Assaubayeva to tell her he would not play the fast classical game, but could not find her. He then expected the tournament directors to pass on the message, but it was not delivered.

The controversy began after Magnus Carlsen went winless in his 10 group-stage fast classical games and was left competing for places 17-20. He then faced Bibisara Assaubayeva. Photo: Total Chess.

Carlsen maintained that the Total Chess format had potential, suggesting a seeded group draw and all three formats every day. However, he stopped short of committing to another appearance.

He also said the physical demands were not the central problem. "It's just that, fundamentally, I don't want to spend my time on it."

Carlsen said he was more likely than not to play Norway Chess next year and that there was a good chance he would compete at the World Rapid and Blitz Championships in Istanbul, Türkiye, on December 26-30.

"It's a bit more manageable at five days. I just think this is very long and tiring."

Previous Coverage:

Chess.com LLC published this content on November 21, 2026, and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed via Public Technologies (PUBT), unedited and unaltered, on November 21, 2026 at 19:20 UTC. If you believe the information included in the content is inaccurate or outdated and requires editing or removal, please contact us at [email protected]