11/18/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/18/2026 11:35
Washington, D.C. - During a Senate Agriculture Committee hearing today considering nominations to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), Senator Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) called out CFTC Chairman Michael Selig for misleading the Committee while under oath on his stance on prediction markets.
Schiff highlighted that despite Selig previously telling the Committee that he would "follow what the courts say," under his unilateral leadership, the CFTC has intervened in prediction market litigation and sued 12 states for attempting to enforce their own gambling laws.
"Over the last two years, the rapid growth of prediction markets has allowed users to gamble on just about anything…These markets are operating in a Wild West, desperately in need of regulation and guardrails," Senator Schiff said during the exchange.
"During his confirmation hearing, I asked Chairman Selig a simple question of whether a prediction contract on who wins or loses a football game is sports betting. He told me that he would be a blank slate on whether prediction markets were gambling and that he would defer to the courts… But he has been anything but a blank slate. He has not looked to the courts. He's filed briefs to tell the courts what to do, and when the courts have ruled in a way that doesn't favor the prediction markets, he has basically told companies to ignore the courts, ignore court orders, don't geofence, don't respect state or Tribal laws. Anything but a blank slate. I don't know that I've ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before" Senator Schiff said.
Schiff also pressed Nathan Amonick, nominee to be Commissioner of the CFTC, on whether he would defer to the courts and respect state and Tribal laws on prediction market regulation. Since his confirmation, Chairman Selig has yet to appear before the Senate Agriculture Committee.
Watch the full clip here
Read the full transcript below:
Schiff: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Anonick, and Mr. Rowland, congratulations on your nominations. Thank you for your service to the Committee and to the Senate.
Currently, we have only one Senate-confirmed Commissioner, and I'm glad that the Committee is considering a bipartisan pair of Commissioner nominees today, it is long overdue.
Over the last two years, the rapid growth of prediction markets has allowed users to gamble on just about anything. In many cases, these contracts are offered in direct contravention of state and tribal law. They create rampant opportunities for insider trading. Too often, they are offered with no regard for national security or even basic morality. The rapid growth of these prediction markets has been fueled by billions of dollars in sports betting, illegally offered on prediction market platforms in all 50 states and on tribal lands. These markets are operating in a wild west, desperately in need of regulation and guardrails.
During his confirmation hearing, I asked Chairman Selig a simple question of whether a prediction contract on who wins or loses a football game is sports betting. He told me that he would be a blank slate on whether prediction markets were gambling and that he would defer to the courts. In fact, I can't tell you how many times he told me exactly that, "Mr. Senator," he said. "It would be irresponsible for me to prejudge that issue. I will look to the courts." In answer to another question, "Senator, I, again, would look to the courts on these questions of facts and interpretation of the law. It's a complex issue. I will follow what the courts say." And again, "Senator, on this issue, I would look to the courts. So, I would look to what the courts say about the issue." And I asked him if I'm betting on a Bills game, or what would you say about that? "Well, there are many lengthy opinions have been written on one word in statute, and I want the benefit of understanding what the judges think about the issue," and again, "I think it would be irresponsible for me to prejudge that issue." And so, I would come to the issue, into the issue at the commission, have confirmed with a blank slate, and look to the courts, because I asked him whether he had a preconceived idea, whether he was a tabula rasa, he said he was a blank slate. Well, I don't know whether he was just lying to us, or once he was confirmed, he had some kind of an epiphany. But he has been anything but a blank slate. He has not looked to the courts. He's filed briefs to tell the courts what to do, and when the courts have ruled in a way that doesn't favor the prediction markets, he has basically told companies to ignore the courts, ignore court orders, don't geofence, don't respect state or tribal laws. Anything but a blank slate. I don't know that I've ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before. This is certainly not the kind of leadership that we need at CFTC. So, Mr. Anonick, let me ask you really the same question I asked him: If I bet using a prediction market on who will win this Thursday's NFL game between the Colts and the Texans, is that a sports bet?
Nathan Anonick: Senator, thank you for that question, and I can only speak for myself, not anyone else. I do think that question, from a legal perspective, is complex, and that federal courts have disagreed on that.
Schiff: Okay, but is it really complex? I mean, if we're betting on who wins a football game on Thursday night, it kind of sounds like a sports bet, right?
Anonick: I certainly appreciate the practical argument. I just say it's legally complex.
Schiff: If betting on who wins a football game is not a sports bet, can you tell me what a sports bet is?
Anonick: I agree, Senator, that the fact that there's been different federal courts' opinions makes that question confusing. But it is an issue that the federal courts have disagreed with. Again, I can only speak for myself, Senator.
Schiff: Well, let me ask you: Are you a tabula rasa? Are you a blank slate? Are you going to defer to the courts, or are you going to act like our current Chairman and tell the courts what to do?
Anonick: Senator, if confirmed, the Supreme Court reaches a decision on this. I would fully support that the CFTC needs to follow that decision, regardless of the decision.
Schiff: And are you going to take a position in that litigation and tell the Supreme Court that you think that states and Tribes should not have a say; that companies should ignore court orders if they don't defer to the CFTC and its jurisdiction. Is that the position you're going to take, the same as the Chair?
Anonick: Senator, I'm not trying to be evasive. I don't know a position I would take on anything. If I was confirmed and there was a matter before me, and I would take the role as Commissioner seriously. I think that means a robust, thorough fact-finding process. That means talking to Office of General Counsel. That means talking to outside counsel, that means talking to the Tribes and the states and all of the stakeholders. And anything before me would be my own decision, and I would own that. But out of respect for the seriousness that I think being a commissioner requires, and going through that robust process, I don't have a preconceived position because it would be irresponsible of me to make that position until I've gone through that process.
Schiff: I just hope that I don't have another confirmation hearing for another proposed nominee and have to read your testimony back. I hope you'll be true to what you've just said, and approach this with an open mind, and hear the stakeholders, including the states and the Tribes, and their perspective before you make a judgment.
I thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.
###