11/18/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/18/2026 13:56
Recent studies have revealed that only 13 percent of the country's 8th graders are proficient in U.S. history. And two out of three American adults wouldn’t pass the citizenship test routinely given as part of the naturalization process.
In these numbers, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch sees an urgency that led him and his co-author, Janie Nitze, to write “Heroes of 1776,” a children’s book aimed at not just celebrating the ideas our country is built on, but at making sure students understand them from the very beginning of their education. On this episode of Access to Excellence, President Gregory Washington is joined by Justice Gorsuch and Nitze to discuss the value of civic education in the 21st century.
President Gregory Washington (00:00)
Recent studies have revealed that only 13% of the country's eighth graders are proficient in US history, and two out of three American adults wouldn't pass the citizenship test that is routinely given as a part of the naturalization process. In these numbers, US Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch sees an urgency that led him and his co-author, Janie Nitze, to write Heroes of 1776, a children's book aim not just at celebrating the ideas of our country, but also at making sure students understand them from the very beginning of their education. Hello, I'm Gregory Washington, president of George Mason University, and this is Access to Excellence.
President Gregory Washington (01:06)
Heroes of 1776 arrives in our nation's 250th year, and it's born from a worrying thought that a country held together by ideas is in real trouble if people no longer know those ideas. Justice Gorsuch and his former law clerk and frequent co-author, Janie Nitze, are here with us today. Justice Gorsuch, Janie, welcome to the show.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (01:38)
It's a pleasure to be with you, President Washington. Thank you so much for having us.
Janie Nitze (01:43)
Likewise, thank you for having us.
President Gregory Washington (01:44)
And thank you all for being here. It's just great to be able to engage with both of you, and I've been trying to get this connection for some time, so it's great to have you both.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (01:55)
Well, it's such a pleasure to be connected with George Mason University. The law school that you have assembled, both as faculty and the students are truly impressive. I've enjoyed teaching students who've got a serious commitment to public service and have demonstrated it. Your night school program allows so many people who are working to also pursue a law degree at the same time. And I've been fortunate. I've taught CIA agents, F-16 fighter pilots, green berets, all manner of legislative aids on Capitol Hill. And I've really enjoyed my interaction with your students and your faculty, and I consider it a source of pride to be associated with George Mason.
President Gregory Washington (02:47)
Well, you know, that's kind of par for the course. That is what we do. It's one of the things that attracted me to the campus, you know, strivers, people who get, are just trying to better themselves and progress through life and they start at night school and they end up doing great things for the country. You know, it's interesting because when you hear that a sitting Supreme Court justice has written a book, your first thoughts are it's probably a memoir or maybe it's something about law and history or some connection to originalism or some framework as such. But instead, you have written a children's book. So you asked the question, first and foremost, why?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (03:36)
Well that's a good question. One I ask myself, you know, my day job is far away from little kids as possible and my children are now grown. But I have, uh, like you, President, been concerned about the state of civic education in our country for some time. The statistics you cited in your opening have really haunted me. As I've said many times before, I don't fear any external problem with this country. If there are troubles to come, they're gonna be from within. And I think one thing that can really help us as a country is to remember that we share and what unites us, what we share is so much more profound and important than the things that separate us. And I've been involved in a variety of civic education projects through the National Constitutional Center in Philadelphia, Colonial Williamsburg, over the years, iCivics, another great organization.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (04:44)
But Janie, who's here with us, is a mother of young children, and she said, "Oh, man, you should stop complaining about these things and do something about it." And she persuaded me we could, we could manage to put something useful together about the Declaration. And I gotta tell you, it was so much fun. It's always fun to work with one of your favorite people, as Janie is one of mine. But what we produced, I think, was a beautiful book, just beautifully illustrated by Chris Ellison. Uh, and I hope it's a book that not only children will enjoy, but their parents might too. C.S. Lewis wrote that, you know, a good kid's book is, is one that can entertain the parents and maybe tell them something they don't know either. And there were just so many wonderful stories surrounding the Declaration and its adoption. Um, many well-known, but, but quite a few not so well-known. And we tried to put some of those in the book too.
President Gregory Washington (05:42)
Outstanding, outstanding. So, so to both of you, you framed this as a supply and demand situation, right? That parents and communities need to demand better civics education, and then local governments will respond. But from the data that we just highlighted, the survey show that two of three adults would fail the citizenship test themselves. So isn't that asking people to demand what they actually don't know? How do we break the cycle?
Janie Nitze (06:15)
Yeah, so certainly the statistics out there on civic knowledge are quite dismal, as you point out. Beyond the statistic you point, I recently learned that only about a third of Americans can point to the Declaration of Independence as a source of the phrase, "All men are created equal." Another third don't know the three branches of government, let alone sort of how their separation promotes liberty and equality. Um, that said, there's actually some hopeful statistics out there as well. So I also learned that about 80, 90% of parents think that civic education is important and believe that more of it should be taught in our schools. And that's, of course, a, a bipartisan demand. And so I think that many of sort of the schools and communities can, um, latch onto that interest of parents and start to offer more civic education programs in the schools.
Janie Nitze (07:07)
And I think there are a lot of actually green shoots around the country, and that's one of the things that makes me hopeful in this space, that in the last few years alone, we've seen a huge push, not just at the university level, but also in the high schools, middle schools, and elementary schools to include more civic education. And so just in the last few years, there have been a number of states that have introduced legislation and passed legislation increasing the civic education prerequisites for high school graduation, for example. And so, so not all states and, and the requirements are not that robust yet, but it's a positive trend moving forward. And so there is this knowledge gap, but it's not really meant by an interest gap, I would say.
President Gregory Washington (07:44)
No, that's so true. So, Justice Gorsuch, your books for both adults and children stress that the United States is a nation built on a creed, shared ideas, not ethnicity, and you've gotten a little bit of pushback on that. What does that tell you about where the conversation on civics actually stands right now?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (08:09)
Well, I think the conversation on civics is, as Janie says, there's reason for hope. We have to be confident that we can talk about these things in a, in a nonpartisan fact-based way. That's very important to the credibility of any institution trying to do civics well, I think, is it, it is a trustworthy institution to get things right and, and to speak in way that, ways that everybody can receive. But my point, my point in those conversations, pretty simple. Declaration has three big ideas in it. What are those ideas? One, that all of us are created equal. Second, that our creator has endowed us with certain unalienable rights: life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness. And third, that we have the right to rule ourselves. Now, those three ideas do not speak to race. They do not speak to ethnicity. They do not speak to religion.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (09:08)
They speak to every human heart. And I think they're three perfect ideas. They are our nation's creed. They are our aspirations. I like to think of the declaration as a report card. There's something we can measure how we're doing against those ideas through history. And in fact, they've always been called upon, right, as kind of a report card. You know, the women at Seneca Falls, yes, all men are created equal. So are women. Lincoln during the Civil War and Frederick Douglass, you know, what does all men are created equal mean by God? And how are we doing all that? Martin Luther King standing outside Lincoln's Memorial in 1963, hoping that those promises would become more real in our society. So I don't think that those ideas are limited to any class, creed, or color, and I think it's a grave mistake to think they are.
President Gregory Washington (10:07)
Great answer. So Janie, how, or did the process of writing for children change the way you define or approach civic knowledge? And if so, how?
Janie Nitze (10:21)
Yeah, I would say when, sort of a few years ago when the Justice and I started talking about a children's book, thinking about a children's book, I would have confined in my worldview civic education to really sort of raw factual knowledge. So what are the ideas and declarations the Justice spoke to? What are the rights in our constitution? What are the three branches of government? And through conversations with the Justice, as we started to think about what do we want the book to look like? How do we want it structured? What do we want to focus on? I came to a better appreciation about the importance of civic virtue, um, in civic education. And so in our book, we, we certainly cover a particular moment of history and how the Declaration of Independence came about, what are the ideas in the Declaration of Independence at an age appropriate level, but we also found it important to include some sense of the character of the founding generation, of the virtues of that generation.
Janie Nitze (11:16)
So their courage, their sense of sacrifice for a greater cause, the sense of duty and honor of many of the soldiers that joined the Continental Army when they, they knew it was woefully unprepared, untrained, um, as compared to the British Army. And I think many of us nowadays know, you know, about Thomas Jefferson and John Adams and their signature on the Declaration of Independence. So in the end didn't cost them that much. They went on to be presidents of the United States, but we through the book really wanted to focus on some of the lesser known signers and people from that era. And for many of the signers, you know, they ended up much worse off, in part, because they were targeted by the British for this really treasonous act. So some saw sons killed in the war, captured in the war. Over a third had their homes damaged, destroyed. Many who at the start, started off quite wealthy ended up totally impoverished, depended on family and friends for survival.
Janie Nitze (12:16)
Um, and I, I think the civic virtue piece, I've come to appreciate really also by having three young kids, is not emphasized so much in schools today. I picked up just a few weeks ago a early reader for kids that was used in the 1850s, and I did so after reading an op-ed about the readers, they called them McGuffey Readers, and I've been going through it with my six-year-old sons who were the first grade level, and he's been reading from it to me. And, and two things struck me. One was it was beautifully written, but also each lesson imparts some moral lesson for the child. And I wonder how much of that we're doing nowadays. And so just sort of to circle back to your question, I've come to, I think, through writing a book for children with the Justice, through the conversations with the Justice, really to appreciate the importance of civic virtue in that civic education piece.
President Gregory Washington (13:08)
Let's talk a little bit about education in general. Justice Gorsuch, you went to Columbia for its core curriculum, the Great Books requirement, and by your own account, to intentionally not be surrounded by like-minded students. So, so talk about how important that is to a college education and how did it shape your perspective on cynics?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (13:36)
Well, I certainly went to Columbia's that true to say, uh, for the Great Books curriculum. Um, and it's still there today, that much is true. And I just read an op-ed the other day in the Wall Street Journal where kids at Harvard are apparently desperate to get into a class that's super hard and graded, super difficult, and it resembles the Columbia core curriculum to a T. They, they finally figured it out at Harvard, I guess. But I do think that you need to know a certain amount of our history in order to become an effective and good citizen of it, and you need to have some of the virtues that Janie was talking about in order for it to work. Jefferson said that if you expect people to be both ignorant and free, you expect something that's never happened in the history of the world and never will.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (14:34)
So self-government, that last part of the declaration calls on each of us to participate at some level or another, um, in our government. And to do that to, without a knowledge of history, I think is very difficult. I think often we think today, uh, oh boy, what those old dogs might learn from us: the internet, the AI, and all the things we know that they didn't. But boy, what did they know? They knew quite a lot about character. Um, don't you think your grandpa knew a few things about character and your grandmother? And I think in the same way when we look back through the pages of history, we're gonna find in it things that challenge us, things that are difficult, but also things that really can inspire us. Uh, and that's another thing I took from C.S. Lewis as we were working on this, as Janie reminded me, Lewis also said, don't hide difficult things from children.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (15:32)
They're going to face challenges in their life, and it can inspire them to see how you might reach one of those challenges and overcome it. And you do them no favors by hiding that from them because those challenges are gonna come. And, and so we tell those stories in the book. We went back and forth, for example, over... There was a great, there's a great bit in the book when the men are signing the declaration on August 4th, and it's a very solemn and somber affair because they know they're, they're signing themselves up to treason and are subject to, to being hung for what they've done. Their lives are truly at stake. And in Independence Hall where there have been so much debate and, and, and conviviality and disagreement and consensus, there was silence as they went up to sign one by one.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (16:26)
And there was a fat delegate, and there was a skinny delegate. And the fat delegate said to the skinny delegate, "Well, at least when they come to hang us, I will die quickly and you will swing in the air for an hour or two."President Gregory Washington (17:19)
Justice Neil Gorsuch (17:20)
So it went back in. So it went back in.
President Gregory Washington (17:22)
That's interesting. Look, this civics education piece is a big debate piece in higher ed today, right? It's one of the things where people believe, well, you should already have an idea of basic civics before you come to university, right? It's about you being educated and qualified to get here. And then there's another group that says, well, we haven't really done a good job at that. And it's clear by the directions and, and the outcomes we see in the country. So we should do a better job of doing our part to help this propagate, right? And you know, as we debate these issues, where do you think universities sit in this? What, what should our part be?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (18:31)
Jane, you wanna take a stab at that first?
Janie Nitze (18:32)
Oh, sure. Well, I think for us, I think George Mason is doing an excellent job at fostering the type of open dialogue and free speech that you'd wanna see on campuses. So I know that it sort of routinely ranks at the top of these rankings of sort of free speech on campuses, and I think that, that's a good start, right? And then I think I'm not sure I can give a better answer than what the Justice gave in the last answer, which is, yes, part of the civic education is about just the raw knowledge piece, right? But a huge part of it is about building sort of the character of the man, the woman. And so here I'm reminded again, when we go back, I often think that the answer to many of these questions just lies in the past.
Janie Nitze (19:11)
So what do our founders think that the purpose of education, a college education was, right? And John Adams wrote to his son, John Quincy Adams, in a beautiful letter, and he said, "Never forget, son, that the end point of study is to make you a good man and a useful citizen," right? And again, that character piece, the virtue piece is so critical, and I certainly agree that colleges have a role there. I also think there's never too young to start with that piece, with a civic knowledge piece. Um, but it seems like colleges nowadays have lost some degree of trust with the public, right? Trust is at a low moment for academic institutions. In part, I think they've forgotten sort of the past, and what is the point of a college education? Yes, there's a role on campuses to talk about current events, to debate those hopefully civilly, but also, um, to understand our society.
Janie Nitze (20:06)
We do need to look back to this classical model, understand the literature that formed us, the history that formed us, and look to these sort of character building, um, uh, character building exercises, literature, et cetera, to satisfy, again, sort of this broader civic virtue piece of education.
President Gregory Washington (20:26)
You know, so much of civics is under pressure, it's under controversy. You, you highlighted individuals like Frederick Douglas, and you, and you talk about Adams, and you talk about, uh... But, but so much of the founding and the adoption of this creed that binds us all together, it's an experiment, and we are always struggling to live up to it, right? And it's challenged, you know, by key individuals in our history, and that makes up a part of the civics question, in my mind. That's a part of that framework. It's built out of that challenge. It's built out of people looking at that creed and pointing to the country and saying, "The country is not there right now. The country is partially there, or the country is way, uh, very, very, very far from it." And universities have been thrust in this framework where they must simultaneously protect, protect freedom of expression and maintain an environment where students can learn without harassment, without discrimination and the like.
President Gregory Washington (21:59)
What constitutional principles, relative to civics, relative to our formation, should guide universities and universities leaders like myself when these responsibilities appear in conflict?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (22:14)
Boy, that's over my pay grade, President. That's, uh, you know, I'm not a university president. I've got my own set of issues. But, you know, I do think a couple of things that Janie touched on are completely right, right? Which is, uh, you know, of course, it's very important for us to learn technical knowledge, right? And, and part of what maybe has contributed to the decline in civic educations in the lower rungs of our educational system has been the influx of STEM curricula over the last generation or two. And that's pushed out certain other things. Um, but I think we're, we're foolish if we think that a republic can stand without some basic knowledge about history, character, and a respect for one another as persons.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (23:13)
Those two things cannot be mutually exclusive. We have to make room for both. Uh, we are the longest lived democracy in the world. We've been very good at this. We are not perfect. We've not realized the declarations promise. I think it will always be a journey to do that. Um, but we are very good and have been historically. And so I don't think it takes much to, to look back and see how that knowledge has been transmitted from generation to generation and, and take some of the best practices of it and make sure that we're doing those things still. Um, and if we're not doing them, maybe you find ways to reinsert them in our curricula. Uh, but I do think, yes, you, you've got to educate people in technical matters, but I think you also have to make room for these things too.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (24:09)
This is part of a university's role, no less than it is a high school or a grade school, all an appropriate age level curricula. But you're building character, you're building citizens too. Even, even when you're - even when you're also building an electrical engineer.
President Gregory Washington (24:29)
That's right. No, I agree with that. And that in essence is part of the challenge, right? How do you do these things simultaneously? Janie, you, you got any thoughts on this?
Janie Nitze (24:45)
Oh, gosh. I'm not sure I can add all that much more to what the Justice said. I'm always reminded by one thing the Justice points to in, in conversations like these, which is if you go back to sort of the early 1800s, for example, right, what did our republic look like then? Well, we had the Secretary of the Treasury engage in a duel with the Vice President of the United States, a duel that ended in a death, right? We had multiple instances of senators caning each other, pulling out pistols on each other on the floor of the Senate. We had one senator being imprisoned by a sitting president, being reelected from prison, and we had at some point in the 19th century, an all-out brawl involving 30 to 50 members on the floor of the house with people crawling over desks and fist fighting and the like.
Janie Nitze (25:31)
And so those are not sort of ideals for us to look up to necessarily, but they do, I think, put some context in our current, current moment of we've always had disagreements in the past, right? But that is part of what democracy is built out of, the fact that we can each voice our own opinion, hopefully tolerate each other's opinions, sift through the opinions, and then choose the best one. So I'd only say again here, my constant refrain, which is I think the past is a lot to offer us in understanding our current moment.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (25:59)
Janie's hit on what, what I forgot to say as usual. But you know when people say, "Oh, doom and gloom," I, I do think, "Okay, well, you know, I'm not here to tell you our times aren't challenging." They are. They're definitely challenging.Justice Neil Gorsuch (26:51)
Another guy who said--everybody said he wanted to, wanted to engage in revolution. And, and, and there were some questions about his sexual past, okay, that were out in the newspapers, and a third guy who, who wound up, as Janie said, shooting dead the secretary of the treasury. Now, that was, that was John Adams, Thomas Jefferson and Aaron Burr. So those are your three choices for president in 1801. And Adams and Jefferson, about that time, each of them in their different ways are kind of expressing some regret, uh, about the constitution they've created, about this country that they've...and some uncertainty about whether it would succeed over the long run. Um, so if Jefferson and Adams can wonder about those things, you know, imagine how proud they'd be if they could see us today. And wouldn't you say they'd be enormously proud of us?
President Gregory Washington (27:49)
I think that they would be very, very, very proud. And I think that they would, they would say, no, not in my wildest dreams that I think it would wind up here, right?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (28:01)
Yeah. They, they'd say, "You got problems? We had problems," right? And so I think it's a, a little perspective on our challenges is warranted too, and that comes through studying history.
President Gregory Washington (28:15)
No, that's right. So the kind of education we're talking about, uh, this whole civics framework is really rooted in classics, right? These documents are not easy documents to read or understand. Uh, it's built on a specific type of intellectual work, careful reading, careful writing, learning, uh, how to challenge and how to be challenged. A lot of work now is being done with the help of AI in this framework. Does AI change the relationship, our relationship with civics? Does it change the civic formation argument? Or does it make the argument even more urgent? How does it affect the way in which we are going to learn and consume this topic?
Janie Nitze (29:13)
Yeah, maybe I'll, I'll take a stab at that one. Um, I'll actually go back. So the Justice alluded to a Wall Street Journal article. I read it too yesterday. Um, and as the Justice said, it's about this class at Harvard: Humanities 10 that is a total throwback to the past, right? You're not allowed to have digital devices, it's apparently quite hard. You read one or two classics a week, you know, The Odyssey, The Iliad, authors like Dante, Plato, Espinoza, and, and the more. And, and kids are just fighting to get into the class. And there's a long wait list, I think 100 people are rejected. And what's remarkable about that is Wall Street Journal went around and interviewed some of the student, said, "Why are you trying so hard to get into this actually quite difficult class where you're not at all guaranteed an A?" And they said something that stuck with me, which was: what we get out of this class is something closer to the human experience, which is not what we're getting out of AI.
Janie Nitze (30:05)
And they specifically called out, we're not getting it from AI. And so in this weird way, AI was creating in these group of students, a yearning for return to the past, to return to classics, a return to what they term themselves or to the human experience. So I have no doubt that AI will change campuses. You, of course, President Washington know far better than I do how it's changing at a minimum. Professors, I'm sure, are dealing with essays that are half written by AI. But, but maybe in this odd way, it's going to return us not just to campuses, you know, in a pre-AI world, but almost in a pre-digital device world where devices aren't used, essays are written by hand, and we're really focusing more on the text because the students are demanding it more, wanting it more, or feeling the sort of emptiness in their lives more.
Janie Nitze (30:55)
So I don't know. I think it'll have sort of... For all the death and gloom people talk about AI I too was fascinated by that article because I think it suggests a glimmer of hope in it all.
President Gregory Washington (31:03)
Humans wanna be with humans.
Janie Nitze (31:06)
Correct.President Gregory Washington (31:08)
Justice?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (31:09)
Yeah, no, I think that's right. I think that's right. I don't know. I just hope AI doesn't come from my job.President Gregory Washington (31:24)
Justice Neil Gorsuch (32:09)
Yeah. I don't...Again, I'm gonna stay in my lane.I know more about law school than I do other disciplines, but that $150,000 figure is the average debt load a student, uh, comes out with. And that was some years ago when I looked into it. I'm sure it's much higher now. I mean, tuition bills at, at leading law schools these days are closer to $100,000 a year. Now, that's the sticker price and not everybody pays it, but these kids are walking out with a huge amount of debt from seven years of higher education. And, and the question I've raised is simply, is that necessary? In England, where I think the rule of law is reasonably robust you can become a lawyer after three years of an undergraduate degree. Now, the difference between three and seven is quite a lot.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (33:00)
And at three years, it's not like you're a full-fledged practicing lawyer ready to go. You're a trainee, but you're getting paid rather than paying somebody else for the privilege. And if you want to go on to get a specialized degree, you can. You can get a master's in law or a doctorate in law, as actually I did at Oxford a long time ago. But the fact of the matter is, I think it's worth asking ourselves why we have the year requirements we have, and are, are they, are they adding the value that we expect? Um, I went back and looked why the ABA came up with a three-year law degree. I mean, 100 years ago, great many lawyers didn't go to law school at all, but studied law as Lincoln did in the law offices of a mentor and friend. Um, and that's still possible in some places in this country today, but very few.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (33:51)
Uh, so why did the ABA try and get everybody to have to go to law school for three years? And why three? And the answer turned out they knew that medical school was four and they though law school's almost as important.President Gregory Washington (34:39)
You know, we are asking our faculty and all of our academic units to really look at how would we reimagine education today, you know, in light of all of the changes, in light of AI, in light of some of these other constructs. And I'm interested to see what they come forward with. Your commentary, what you just highlighted is the kind of thing they actually need to hear as they're debating and deliberating what these outcomes should actually be, what the new education should look like.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (35:17)
Yeah, it's just that some of it though, you can't influence. Some of it is accreditation requirements, right? And, um, you know, at law school for a long time adjunct teachers like myself were not counted, obviously, as full-time faculty members, and yet I have a certain number of full-time faculty members as a ratio to the students, um, regardless of how many classes they taught. I used to teach at the University of Colorado before Mason, and I teach two classes a year. A full-time professor taught three. That was their requirement. So it wasn't that much different, but yet I can't remember, I counted as a fraction of a faculty member. I can't remember whether it was half or a third or whatever crazy number it is, but you just have to ask yourself, do all these accreditation requirements necessarily yield better outcomes? If outcomes are what we're concerned about, why are we meticulously regulating every shot and tittle of the input rather than the output?
President Gregory Washington (36:20)
So let me ask this question of both of you as we start to kind of wrap up here. So 44 states have introduced civics related legislation in 2025, but surveys actually show that teachers are actively avoiding anything that could be called controversial, right? As you just highlighted, the nature of civics is embroiled and connected in controversy, right? So how do you remind people that actual disagreement is a part of our democratic process?
Janie Nitze (36:55)
I just think this goes back to the answer to a prior question. I think it's all about the past. I think you talked to them about the duel, the canings, you talked to them about, you know, all that we've gone through as a nation, all the disagreements that we've had, and then how we've sorted our way out of those disagreements. And I think you talked to them about what a democracy means, right? How are we to arrive at the best outcome if we don't have competing views, if we don't respect those competing views, tolerate those competing views? I'm a big fan of debate classes and courses, the ways to hone those skills in the students, have them pick a topic that they don't necessarily agree with, force them to really live it and argue it, and I think they'll come to a better appreciation of the other side on that topic. So I think, I think all these, all these things, looking to the past, creating moments in the day for the student when they can appreciate how to sort of tolerate opposing views, I think that's all part of the puzzle.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (37:52)
I think I added that a couple of things. One is, yes, the past is full of difficult subject matters, but it's also fascinating, right? And you, as I alluded to earlier, you find people in it, whoever you are, uh, that you're going to learn something from and admire. One of the stories we tell in the book, Thomas Nelson, was one of the signers of the Declaration, and he actually led the Virginia militia at the Battle of Yorktown. And when, you know, legend has it that, you know, when he saw that the British were using his home as a headquarters, he didn't hesitate to order troops to fire on it. Uh, and he died so impoverished because he gave so much of his money to the cause of freedom that when, when he passed, his family actually had to bury him in an unmarked grave because they were afraid creditors would come dig him up and use his body as collateral for his debts.
Justice Neil Gorsuch (38:58)
And yet when he was dying, he was asked if he had any regrets and he said, "None at all. I'd do it all over again." And there are so many men and women, children, we've got in the book, some wonderfully courageous children in this book who helped men, women, children, Black, white, Native American who were involved in this struggle. And there is something for all of us. We can find inspiration, each and every one of us can find inspiration history. We shouldn't be afraid of it. We shouldn't be afraid of it. And yes, it can be difficult, but we shouldn't be afraid of it. And second, the second point I'd say is we have to be able to learn how to do it in a fact-based way that, that is robustly nonpartisan and respectful of one another. And if we can do those two things, dig into it and do it in a way that all of us can be heard and hear, I think, it's been done in the past, it's been done for 250 years, it can be done again.
President Gregory Washington (40:05)
So this is really good, and this leads to the last question. I got one for you, Justice Gorsuch, and one's for you, Janie, as we wrap up. And it's directly connects to your last statement here. So Justice Gorsuch, is there a version of civic renewal that works in a country that's divided as we are?
Justice Neil Gorsuch (40:31)
I see, I see it happening all around us. I'm sorry to interrupt, but I'm just so eager to get out the answer as, you know, I work, uh, I work with the US Constitution Center in Philadelphia. I work with the folks down at Colonial Williamsburg. iCivic:, my dear friends, Justice Sotomayor, sits on their board. I've done some things with them as well. Those are organizations that do exactly what we're talking about. They tackle the difficult, hard parts of history. They tell it all the good, the bad, the ugly, and they do it in a scrupulously fact-based way that's nonpartisan. So yes, yes, it can absolutely be done, and it's being done in c- countless classrooms throughout this country. We should... Do not be afraid. It can be done.
President Gregory Washington (41:18)
Okay, Janie, last question to you. You have two youngsters, right? Hearing all of this, being a part of this process, what makes you hopeful?
Janie Nitze (41:30)
Great last question. What makes me hopeful? I'm hopeful by conversations like this, institutions like yours. I'm hopeful when I read the Wall Street Journal article saying that students are scrambling to get into a humanities course, right, teaching the Iliad and talking about Dante. I'm hopeful I've read statistics recently that there have been other 46 centers devoted to civic education at campuses across the country. And over half of them were formed since 2021. And I just love that statistics because it shows just such a positive trend in this direction. So yes, the statistics on civic knowledge are dismal, yes, but the trend on this is all up. People are having the conversation, people are starting to care. So I'm quite hopeful about where we can go from here.
President Gregory Washington (42:18)
Look, my conversation with both of you has been outstanding, and it's actually reminded me of something. Uh, it's a line from an American poet, Archibald McLeash, who famously wrote, "Democracy is never a thing done. Democracy is always something that a nation must be doing." The work of citizenship is always something in progress, and the role we play at George Mason is that progress is, we hope, part of what makes us all together different. Thank you all for listening. We'll see you next time and on the next episode of Access to Excellence.