National Marine Fisheries Service

11/19/2026 | News release | Distributed by Public on 11/19/2026 13:09

New Research Finds Culling Seals, Sea Lions in the Ocean Unlikely to Benefit Salmon

New research by scientists from NOAA Fisheries and Oregon State University finds widespread ocean culling of seals, sea lions, and seabirds is unlikely to improve salmon abundance. Other predators and competitors in the ocean are likely to offset any reduction in pinniped or seabird predation, the research found.

The research paper was published in the journal Science. The research grew from efforts to better understand salmon survival in a changing ocean and to estimate the effects of predation, competition, and management.

The research uses an ecosystem model to assess the effects of changes to the Northern California Current marine food web. Previous research largely examined only the direct impacts of predators on salmon. The model goes further by exploring indirect effects across the food web, such as how other species may respond to changes.

"This gives us a more holistic view, not only of what happens to salmon but what happens across the ecosystem when you start making changes," said Dylan Gomes, who led the research while a postdoctoral researcher at NOAA Fisheries' Northwest Fisheries Science Center and Oregon State University. "When we look at the ecosystem as a whole, we see that one change can lead to a set of cascading effects that may not always be predictable or obvious."

In modeled scenarios, ocean reductions of pinnipeds and seabirds generally produced small and uncertain net changes in Chinook and coho salmon biomass. Pinnipeds also consume competitors and predators of salmon such as hake and jack mackerel, so reducing pinnipeds can allow other species to compete with or consume salmon.

For example, reducing pinnipeds that also prey on hake can leave more hake to compete with and prey on young salmon. Hake biomass in the modeled area is about 370 times the biomass of pinnipeds. Even though hake diets include only small amounts of juvenile salmon, their total impact on salmon in the ocean is much greater.

"Climate change will alter trophic interactions throughout the ecosystem," said Lisa Crozier, a research scientist at the Northwest Fisheries Science Center and a coauthor. "So we need to be careful when assuming that the small parts that we see represent the most important aspects for salmon. NOAA Fisheries and other agencies collect data across dozens of surveys. Ecosystem modeling is one way to integrate all of that information into a more realistic picture of the salmon migration."

The model indicates that reductions in hake yielded a greater increase in salmon biomass than reducing pinnipeds. However, increasing hake fisheries is not necessarily a solution as the hake fishery is the largest fishery by volume on the West Coast. The fishery also impacts salmon directly through bycatch, potentially reducing any benefit to salmon.

"Ecosystem modeling blends scientific inquiry with model development. Our study accounts for the indirect effects that changes to predator populations will have throughout the food web," said Jim Ruzicka, an ocean ecologist at NOAA's Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center and a coauthor of the research. "We hope the techniques we have developed and employed here will help foresee and plan for the impacts of both natural and human stressors upon West Coast salmon and food web dynamics."

Modeled scenarios showed that salmon biomass was more sensitive to changes in other predator and prey groups than to widespread pinniped reductions. Additional scenarios indicated that, at the fleet level, changes in fisheries also did not substantially impact salmon.

The ecosystem model is designed to assess how changes in management may affect the marine food web on a regional scale. It does not assess site-specific impacts including predation on salmon at migratory bottlenecks such as fish ladders. The authors recognize that such bottlenecks can expose salmon to greater predation They do not rule out that targeted removals at those sites, pursuant to section 120 of the Marine Mammal Protection Act, may have a role in salmon conservation.

NOAA Fisheries policies have long focused on site-specific interventions where habituated animals have documented impacts on vulnerable salmon. They do not advocate the kind of widespread culling examined by the research. Earlier studies indicated management actions are most efficient when they remove problematic individuals promptly, before other pinnipeds pick up the same opportunistic foraging behaviors.

National Marine Fisheries Service published this content on November 19, 2026, and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed via Public Technologies (PUBT), unedited and unaltered, on November 19, 2026 at 19:09 UTC. If you believe the information included in the content is inaccurate or outdated and requires editing or removal, please contact us at [email protected]