Douglas Man Previously Convicted of Hate Crimes and Arson Sentenced to More than 36 Years (DOJ)

Press Release

TUCSON, Ariz. - Eric Duane Ridenour, 58, of Douglas, was sentenced yesterday by United States District Judge Scott H. Rash to 438 months in prison. On July 11, 2024, Ridenour was convicted at trial of six arson and hate crimes counts stemming from the burning of two churches on May 22, 2023.

In 2023, Ridenour burned down two churches in Douglas, Arizona: Saint Stephen's Episcopal Church and First Presbyterian Church. The churches were located on Church Square, a historic district in the border town of Douglas, approximately two hours southeast of Tucson. It is believed to have been the only intersection in the nation containing churches from four different denominations: Southern Baptist, Presbyterian, Episcopal, and Methodist. Trial testimony established that Ridenour intentionally started the fires in both churches because of his hostility towards their practice of having women and members of the LGBTQ community serve in church leadership roles. Ridenour was arrested on May 23, 2023.

"This is a case about two separate arsons and the motivations behind each," said United States Attorney Gary Restaino. "Defendant burned a church because he disagreed with its position that women and LGBTQ individuals may serve as ministers, and then he burned a second church, in the same historic square, for the same reason. Destruction of religious institutions is abhorrent to our Constitution. I add my voice to the prayers for healing in the Douglas community."

"ATF is dedicated to protecting the rights of all Americans. We strongly share the same concerns of United States Attorney Restaino and the community. The sentencing of Ridenour is a testament to the collaborative work between all agencies involved in this investigation," said ATF Phoenix Special Agent in Charge Brendan Iber. "We are proud to provide the expertise of the ATF Certified Fire Investigators (CFI) to assist in this prosecution. We remain committed to seeking justice and ensuring the safety of our community".

"There is no way to undo the damage Mr. Ridenour caused with his hateful and violent behavior, but we hope this sentence provides some measure of comfort," said FBI Phoenix Special Agent in Charge Jose A. Perez. "We will continue to work with our law enforcement partners to investigate and ensure those who perpetrate such acts of hate are held accountable."

Vindicating the victim churches' rights in this case is part of a larger initiative implemented by this Office. With the creation of a Civil Rights unit in the Civil Division, and the designation of a hate crimes coordinator in the Criminal Divisions, U.S. Attorney Restaino has made the prosecution of hate crimes and the protection of civil rights a cornerstone of his tenure in the Office.

On the civil side, the Office's two civil rights AUSAs have participated in round tables, community meetings, and convenings with community and faith leaders and city and county officials to listen to community concerns and inform the communities about the work of the Office. On the criminal side, as part of the first cohort announced by Attorney General Merrick Garland in September 2022, the Office has participated in the Department's United Against Hate (UAH) initiative, an effort designed to address and prevent unlawful acts of hate. For its UAH efforts, the Office has held five large-scale events, presenting on the importance of hate crime reporting to various underrepresented and often-targeted communities in Phoenix and Tucson. The purpose of the events was to hear from each community about its fears and concerns, start a dialogue between the communities and law enforcement, and get the USAO out into the communities it serves.

The initiative has also resulted in increased civil rights prosecutions. Hate crimes and other bias incidents are unique because they have a devastating impact on entire communities. The USAO prosecuted Eric Celaya for providing guns to a person who then used them to shoot two Jewish community members in California. Celaya pleaded guilty and was sentenced to eight months in prison. The Office indicted Mark Adams Prieto for selling guns that he believed would be used in a mass shooting to incite a race war. In addition to hate crime charges, the Office has also prosecuted law enforcement agents for harming those they are sworn to protect, such as former Customs and Border Protection Officer Aaron Mitchell, convicted at trial for Deprivation of Rights Under Color of Law arising out of the kidnaping and sexual assault of a cross-border student. This Office remains committed to investigating all potential hate crimes and color of law violations, and working closely with local and federal law enforcement to determine whether charges are appropriate.

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and the Douglas Police Department conducted the investigation in this case. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Austin Fenwick, Ben Goldberg, and Adam Rossi, District of Arizona, handled the prosecution.

CASE NUMBER: CR 23-00908-TUC-SHR
RELEASE NUMBER: 2025-001_Ridenour

# # #

For more information on the U.S. Attorney's Office, District of Arizona, visit http://www.justice.gov/usao/az/
Follow the U.S. Attorney's Office, District of Arizona, on X @USAO_AZ for the latest news.

Contact

Updated January 8, 2025